By Quentin Brand
批閱前言
Analyzing the English writing of 112th Kaohsiung Medical University Post-Baccalaureate Medicine is a crucial and meaningful task in the field of English writing strategies. Discussing the statement, “ChatGPT can save lives in the emergency room, but it needs supervision. It is at once both smarter and dumber than any person you’ve ever met,” allows us to delve deeper into this topic and explore the necessary approaches for enhancing future learning and the latest developments in related exam questions.
題 目
Write an essay of at least 200 words regarding the following statement. ‘ChatGPT can save lives in the emergency room, but it needs supervision. ‘It is at once both smarter and dumber than any person you’ve ever met.’ 112 高醫英文
Plan 寫作規劃
| Opinion 論點：agree | |
| For | Against |
|
C support in treatment options Ci access a vast database of medical literature Cii research papers, and clinical trials B: rapidly analyzing extensive patient data A: valuable tool for medical professionals Biii potential diagnoses Bi symptoms, medical history Bii test results Ciii drug interactions, contraindications, dosage adjustments |
Di proper supervision Dv considering patient-specific factors and individualized care D not a replacement for human expertise Diii mitigate any potential risks Dii accuracy of its responses Div interpreting and contextualizing the information |
| C 支持治療方案 Ci 訪問龐大的醫學文獻數據庫 Cii 研究論文和臨床試驗 B：快速分析大量患者數據 A：醫療專業人員的寶貴工具 Biii 潛在診斷 Bi 症狀、病史 Bii 測試結果 Ciii 藥物相互作用、禁忌症、劑量調整 |
D 適當的監督 Dv 考慮患者特定因素和個體化護理 D 不能替代人類的專業知識 Diii 減輕任何潛在風險 Dii 響應的準確性 Div 對訊息進行解釋和語境化 |
範文
It cannot be denied that in the high-pressure environment of emergency rooms, medical professionals face numerous challenges that can impact their decision-making process. Chat GPT could be useful in this situation. However, while this may be true to some extent, it is important to note that ChatGPT should be used as a supportive tool and not a replacement for human expertise. It’s my opinion that within appropriate limits, ChatGPT can be a useful tool. There are several reasons why I think so.
ChatGPT’s application in healthcare settings is wide-ranging. For example, in the emergency room, it can serve as a valuable tool for medical professionals. By rapidly analyzing extensive patient data, including symptoms, medical history, and test results, ChatGPT can assist in the diagnostic process. Moreover, it can provide doctors and nurses with relevant information and potential diagnoses, helping them make well-informed decisions in real-time.
Furthermore, ChatGPT can offer support in treatment options. Take for example the way that it can access a vast database of medical literature, research papers, and clinical trials to provide evidence-based recommendations. In emergency situations ChatGPT can offer insights into potential drug interactions, contraindications, and dosage adjustments.
However, it is important to note that ChatGPT should be used as a supportive tool and not a replacement for human expertise. It requires proper supervision to ensure the accuracy of its responses and to mitigate any potential risks. In addition, human oversight remains critical to interpreting and contextualizing the information provided by ChatGPT, as well as considering patient-specific factors and individualized care.
In summary, I firmly believe that ChatGPT is a valuable tool in the emergency room. However, it is essential to maintain human supervision and expertise to ensure patient safety and the responsible use of this technology.
Q 評析
本文以支持 ChatGPT 在急診室中的應用為立場，並強調了它作為一種有用工具的潛力。以下是本文的結構分析：
＜引言＞
引入急診室高壓環境和醫療專業人員面臨的挑戰。提到 ChatGPT 在這種情況下可能有用。 表明 ChatGPT 應作為一種支持性工具，而不是取代人類專業知識。
＜主段落 1＞
聲明 ChatGPT 在醫療設置中的廣泛應用。以急診室為例，強調 ChatGPT 對醫療專業人員的價值。提到 ChatGPT 可以快速分析患者數據，幫助診斷過程。強調 ChatGPT 可以提供相關訊息和潛在診斷，幫助做出即時的明智決策。
＜主段落 2＞
提到 ChatGPT 可以在治療選擇方面提供支持。 以訪問醫學文獻、研究論文和臨床試驗為例，強調 ChatGPT 的資料庫訪問能力。強調 ChatGPT 可以提供有關藥物相互作用、禁忌症和劑量調整的訊息。
＜反對論點＞
強調 ChatGPT 應作為一種支持性工具，而不是取代人類專業知識。強調 ChatGPT 需要適當的監督來確保回答的準確性並減輕潛在風險。 強調人類監督和專業知識對於解釋、內容化 ChatGPT 提供的訊息以及考慮患者特定因素和個體化護理的重要性。
＜結論＞
強調 ChatGPT 在急診室中是一個有價值的工具。
強調保持人類監督和專業知識的重要性，確保患者安全和負責任地使用該技術。
整體而言，這篇作文清晰地陳述了立場，並以主段落進一步解釋了 ChatGPT 在急診室中的應用。該作文合理地提出了支持的論點，包括迅速分析患者數據、提供診斷支持和治療選擇方面的幫助。同時，它也提到了反對論點，指出 ChatGPT 需要適當的監督和人類專業知識來確保準確性和避免潛在風險。
這篇作文的結構清晰，分段合理。每個段落都有明確的主題句，並通過具體的例子和解釋來支持論點。引言段引起讀者的興趣並概述了整篇文章的立場。主段落提供了具體的論據來支持觀點，並考慮了 ChatGPT 在急診室中的多個應用場景。反對論點段落對監督和人類專業知識的重要性進行了強調。最後，結論段總結了觀點並再次強調了 ChatGPT 作為有價值工具的重要性，同時也強調了人類監督的必要性。
整體而言，這篇作文以清晰結構和明確的論點表達了作者的立場。通過提供具體例子和合理的論證，該作文在論述中展示了對主題的深入思考。
